{"submission_id":"849a4958-775d-4499-a5f9-4053e0e79e36","submission_revision_id":"98399f67-baee-4dd2-a8a7-99ea1b77b255","revision_version":1,"submission_status":"under_review","submitted_at":"2026-09-15T23:43:28.825887Z","submitter_name":"Yichen Wu","submitter_email":"myrealnameisk@outlook.com","task":{"status":"submitted","version":1,"extra_fields":{"difficulty_self_test":{"model":"GPT 6-Astra","harness":"Codex","estimated_score":"<1%"}},"submitted_at":"2026-09-15T23:43:28.825887+00:00","industry_domain":"Document Production / Business Operations","task_short_name":"word_recreation_scm_qa_plan_1","operating_system":"Windows","task_description":"**Objective:** Recreate the provided reference PDF as a fully editable Microsoft Word document (`recreated.docx`) that visually matches the reference as closely as possible when exported back to PDF from Microsoft Word.\n\n**Starting State:** You are provided with `source.pdf`, an 8-page A4 portrait QA-plan template originally exported from Microsoft Word for Microsoft 365 using Word’s built-in PDF export workflow. The document contains a cover page, contents page, numbered sections, repeated headers and footers, page numbers, teal rules and fills, red italic footer text, complex tables with non-uniform column widths and row heights, shaded cells, bordered template panels, bullet lists, placeholders, mixed font formatting, and visible broken Word-reference/error text.\n\n**Instructions & Rules:** Rebuild the document from scratch in Microsoft Word using native Word structures only. Reproduce all visible text and formatting, including typography, line wrapping, paragraph spacing, margins, alignment, table dimensions, column proportions, row heights, borders, fills, headers, footers, and page-level content placement.\n\nText must remain editable Word text, tables must be native Word tables, and headers, footers, borders, shading, and page layout must use appropriate Word-native features.\n\nPreserve the exact 8-page A4 portrait structure and reproduce all visible content exactly as shown, including broken-reference/error strings such as `错误!未定义书签。` and `错误!未找到引用源。`; do not correct them.\n\nDo not use screenshots, rendered PDF pages, embedded PDF pages, rasterized text, full-page background images, or automatic PDF-to-Word conversion. Do not download or reuse an existing Word version, template, or document asset from the internet.\n\nSave the final deliverable as `recreated.docx`. For verification, export it to PDF using Microsoft Word’s built-in PDF export workflow and compare all 8 pages against `source.pdf` for page count, content placement, line wrapping, tables, borders, fills, typography, headers, footers, and overall visual fidelity.\n","software_licensing":"Commercial","evaluation_criteria":null,"verification_method":"Pass only if all of the following conditions are satisfied:\n\nThe Word document exports to exactly 8 A4 portrait pages using Microsoft Word, with the same page-level content distribution as source.pdf.\nAll visible text, numbers, punctuation, placeholders, page numbers, headers, footers, table contents, and visible broken-reference/error strings match the reference with no material omissions, additions, or corrections.\nNo incorrect line wrapping, page breaks, or content overflow is present. Major text blocks, table boundaries, rules, and other structural elements should be positioned within approximately ±2 pt of the reference where Word rendering permits.\nAll major tables and bordered sections structurally match the reference, including column proportions, row heights, cell boundaries, fills, borders, text wrapping, and alignment.\nTypography and formatting visually match the reference, including font family or metric-equivalent font, size, weight, italics, paragraph spacing, indentation, teal fills/rules, and red italic footer text.\nDirect inspection of the .docx confirms native editability: normal text is editable Word text, tables are native Word tables, and headers, footers, borders, shading, and layout use Word-native structures.\nFull-page screenshots, rasterized text, embedded PDF pages, or page-sized background images are not acceptable. The document structure should show normal Word paragraphs, runs, tables, headers, and footers rather than flattened page facsimiles.\nExport the final .docx to PDF in Microsoft Word and compare every page against source.pdf using side-by-side inspection and semi-transparent overlays or difference images. SSIM or similar image-similarity metrics may be used as a secondary diagnostic only.\n\nOverall pass criterion: all 8 pages must preserve the correct content distribution, contain no material text or line-wrapping errors, visually reproduce all major document structures within the stated tolerance, and pass direct inspection for native Word editability.","software_and_version":"Microsoft Word 16.0.20326.20144 (desktop, Windows)","specific_requirements":null,"expected_completion_time":null},"files":[{"file_id":"6618fb52-7428-4498-971f-55d61ec8b8e3","filename":"source.pdf","category":"input_materials","content_type":"application/pdf","size_bytes":299440},{"file_id":"5ad9a9ff-753b-4cb5-b0fb-e181e3ef1d9c","filename":"reference.docx","category":"reference_output","content_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document","size_bytes":54686},{"file_id":"bfb74a09-146a-4d01-96e0-6580001ce0f1","filename":"SCM_QA_Plan_Template.pdf","category":"difficulty_self_test_evidence","content_type":"application/pdf","size_bytes":210394}],"deep_review":{"overall_verdict":"Strong Accept","review_text":"**Overall Verdict:** Strong Accept — The revision is complete, coherent, reachable, and supported by a usable source, native protected reference, and objective fidelity rubric.\n\n**Completeness Check:**\n- Instruction: Complete — clearly specifies the editable Word deliverable, exact eight-page structure, native-document constraints, and prohibited shortcuts.\n- Inputs: Complete — `source.pdf` is a readable, unencrypted, eight-page A4 PDF with extractable text and no embedded page images.\n- Toolchain: Complete — the required Windows and Microsoft Word environment is identified and legally obtainable.\n- Reference output: Complete — `reference.docx` is a valid, macro-free OOXML document containing native paragraphs, eight tables, sections, fields, headers, footers, borders, and shading. Its text includes the deliberate truncations represented in the source.\n- Rubric: Complete — evaluation covers page count, content, geometry, wrapping, typography, table structure, native editability, and prohibited rasterization with measurable tolerances.\n\n**File and Task Reachability:**\nThe attachment set is `reachable`, and the end-to-end task is `reachable`. All three attachments were inspected: `source.pdf`, `reference.docx`, and `SCM_QA_Plan_Template.pdf`. Downloaded sizes matched the manifest; both PDFs are readable, unencrypted eight-page A4 documents without embedded files, JavaScript, forms, or raster page images. The DOCX package passed integrity checks, and its internal relationships, document parts, native structures, and small fallback drawing package were inspected. A stale, non-required external template relationship does not affect rendering because the document’s styles are embedded. The self-test PDF is visibly less faithful than the source but is correctly separated as difficulty evidence rather than the expected output. No attachment was left unreviewed. Microsoft Word was unavailable for an independent DOCX-to-PDF re-export, which is a reviewer-tooling limitation rather than a submission defect; the supplied evidence still establishes a coherent input-to-output and evaluation path. License keys, accounts, tokens, and other credentials are not required from the contributor. Confidential, proprietary, or internal material may be evaluated as submitted evidence without requiring additional disclosure.\n\n**Special Screening:**\nNone — no affirmative evidence supports `ai_synthetic` or `synthetic_defect_fixture`. Public discoverability was not independently checked, so `public_benchmark` is not applied.\n\n**Recommended Changes:**\nThe submission provides valid source, reference, and difficulty evidence with unusually specific verification requirements. No changes are required.","reviewed_at":"2026-09-15T23:51:14.873529Z"},"claim":null}