{"submission_id":"5be1c8fa-89f1-46b0-ab7d-b3d80c28162c","submission_revision_id":"49680a91-dd8f-4089-a6e5-854159a9fc66","revision_version":3,"submission_status":"under_review","submitted_at":"2026-09-26T01:33:03.112777Z","submitter_name":"Hanhong Zhao","submitter_email":"zhanhh188@gmail.com","task":{"status":"submitted","version":3,"extra_fields":{"difficulty_self_test":{"model":"Opus 5"}},"submitted_at":"2026-09-26T01:33:03.112777+00:00","industry_domain":"Visual Media / Graphic Design","task_short_name":"photoshop_01","operating_system":"MacOS","task_description":"Unzip photoshop_inputs.zip into the task workspace to obtain input/.\n\nALE DELIVERY CONTRACT (version ale-delivery):\nThe task directory is shown in the agent's task description. Paths below are relative to that directory; source assets are in input/. Any legacy desktop save instruction or source output filename is superseded only for final delivery: save an editable layered output/final.psd and export the matching output/final.png. Both are mandatory. Preserve the visual goal and operation requirements in the original specification below.\n\nORIGINAL SPECIFICATION (paths normalized for the ALE workspace):\nQuestion\nCreate a 1500×2100 portrait canvas in Photoshop, fill the background with solid green, make a yellow feathered oval light base, place body.png cap.png lemon.png splash.png, create a three-section split can with \"Pen Tool\" \"Layer Mask\" and \"Ctrl+I\", fit and duplicate lemon.png for cuts and decoration, add splash.png with mask, and finish the composite.\n\nQuery\nUse Adobe Photoshop to create a 1500×2100 portrait canvas named can with a solid green background and a soft yellow feathered elliptical light base, place cutout can body and cap assets, split the upright can into three vertically arranged floating centered sections using the Pen Tool Layer Mask and color inversion, embed lemon slices to fit each can cut and duplicate them to decorate the canvas borders, add splash elements with Layer Mask for realistic decoration, and complete a centered three-section split can composite with natural floating perspective and detailed lemon accents.\n\nSub-task\nOpen Adobe Photoshop, click \"File\" → \"New...\" to create a new canvas.\n\tSet parameters:\nName：can\n\tUnit: px\n\tOrientation: Portrait\n\tWidth: 1500 px\n\tHeight: 2100 px\n\tBackground fill: Solid green\nClick \"Create\" to confirm.\nDraw an oval and set its fill color to yellow.\n\tSet parameter:\n\tFeather: 200 px\nClick \"File\" → \"Place Embedded...\" to import body.png and cap.png, adjust their positions to the center of the canvas.\nSelect body.png layer, use \"Pen Tool\" to draw a split curve path, press Ctrl+Enter to convert path to selection, click \"Add Layer Mask\" to hide the lower part of the can body; select cap.png layer, press Ctrl+T to activate \"Free Transform\", hold Shift to compress and adjust perspective to fit the cut.\nSelect the first body section and cap together, adjust the tilt angle, press Ctrl+J to duplicate the first body section layer, select \"Brush Tool\" to restore can body details on the mask.\n\tSet parameters:\n\tSize: 300 px\n\tHardness: 0%\n\tForeground color: White\nUse the \"Brush Tool\" to restore the can body.\nUse \"Pen Tool\" to draw the middle section path, select the top part of the can with \"Pen Tool\", press Ctrl+Enter to convert to selection, then press Ctrl+I to hide this part;do the same for the bottom part of the can to display only the middle section.\nSelect and press Ctrl+J to duplicate the first body section layer, use \"Pen Tool\" to draw the bottom section path, select the upper part of the can with \"Pen Tool\", press Ctrl+Enter to convert to selection, then press Ctrl+I to hide this part to display only the bottom section.\nImport lemon.png.\nPress Ctrl+T and hold Shift to fit the lemon to the cut, duplicate the lemon layer four times for cut fitting and decoration respectively. Adjust layer order to form a three-section split effect.\nImport splash.png.\nClick \"Add Layer Mask\", select \"Brush Tool\".\n\tSet parameters:\n\tForeground color: Black\nUse the Brush Tool to paint over and remove unwanted areas of the splash.\nClick \"File\" → \"Save As...\" to save the project as can.psd, then click \"File\" → \"Export\" → \"Export As...\" to export the final image as can.png.\n\nFile path： input/\nOurput Path： output\n","software_licensing":"Commercial","evaluation_criteria":null,"verification_method":"Unzip photoshop_01.zip into a fresh evaluator directory. Its SHA-256 is 6a2f8d2fd1867dafe00105b05c13a17cbb84964752246551ec6ebeec33fe357f.\nKeep private_reference/ and evaluator files inaccessible to the agent. Stage only input/ from photoshop_inputs.zip in the agent workspace. Both output/final.psd and output/final.png are required.\n\nEnvironment prerequisites: licensed Adobe Photoshop on macOS for the task; Python 3.12 and network access to a GPT-4o-compatible API for evaluation. Application installation, activation and API credentials are supplied by the environment provider.\n\nFrom the extracted evaluation bundle root:\n1. Create a Python 3.12 environment and install the pinned dependencies:\n   python3.12 -m venv .venv\n   source .venv/bin/activate\n   python -m pip install -r requirements.lock.txt\n   python smoke_test.py\n2. Configure OPENAI_API_KEY with a valid GPT-4o API key. Optionally configure OPENAI_API_BASE for your compatible provider; no specific provider is required.\n3. Run the following command, replacing /absolute/agent-workspace with the task workspace:\n   python tasks/visual_media/photoshop_01/evaluate.py --variant-id citrus-can --candidate-png /absolute/agent-workspace/output/final.png --candidate-psd /absolute/agent-workspace/output/final.psd --prompt task_data/visual_media/photoshop_01/citrus-can/input/task_prompt.txt --expert-png private_reference/visual_media/photoshop_01/citrus-can/reference/expert.png --expert-psd private_reference/visual_media/photoshop_01/citrus-can/reference/expert.psd --json-out score.json\n4. Success requires status=SCORED and normalized_score=1.0. A lower scored value is failure. EVALUATION_INFRASTRUCTURE_FAILURE is not an agent score; resolve the dependency or API issue and retry. Do not repair candidate outputs or overwrite earlier score files.\n\nAll executable evaluation dependencies and usage instructions are included in the ZIP. Evaluation is based on final outputs, not trajectory.\nDifficulty self-test estimate: Opus 5 — 0%.\n","software_and_version":"Adobe Photoshop","specific_requirements":null,"expected_completion_time":null},"files":[{"file_id":"63b0189a-908c-4568-af7f-7e22a573aea6","filename":"photoshop_01.zip","category":"reference_output","content_type":"application/zip","size_bytes":28434697},{"file_id":"dfc40747-2662-4765-b930-3fae88c7c692","filename":"photoshop_inputs.zip","category":"input_materials","content_type":"application/zip","size_bytes":4440038}],"deep_review":{"overall_verdict":"Strong Accept","review_text":"**Overall Verdict:** Strong Accept — The submission is complete, internally consistent, safely reachable, and supports an objective end-to-end Photoshop workflow and evaluation.\n\n**Completeness Check:**\n- Instruction: Complete — The prompt clearly specifies the canvas, assets, composition, masking workflow, visual result, and mandatory PSD/PNG deliverables.\n- Inputs: Complete — The four usable RGBA source images and UTF-8 task prompt are present, valid, and identical between the solver and evaluator bundles.\n- Toolchain: Complete — Licensed Photoshop on macOS is supplied, while the evaluator specifies Python 3.12, hash-pinned dependencies, and a compatible visual-judge API.\n- Reference output: Complete — The valid 1500×2100 expert PNG matches a layered 1500×2100 RGB PSD containing the expected 12 visible layers, three masked can sections, five lemon instances, cap, background, light, and masked splash.\n- Rubric: Complete — Artifact integrity, PNG/PSD consistency, editable structure, visible completeness, instruction following, visual consistency, and workmanship are all evaluated.\n\n**File and Task Reachability:**\nThe attachment set is `reachable`, and the end-to-end task is `reachable`. Both `photoshop_01.zip` and `photoshop_inputs.zip` were inspected. Their archive structures, file types, sizes, encryption status, integrity, media dimensions and alpha content, manifest relationships, prompt, reference artifacts, dependency lock, staging logic, and task-relevant scoring rules were reviewed. The evaluation bundle matches its authoritative checksum, all internal payloads match its manifest hashes, both archives pass integrity checks, and no unsafe archive entries or access barriers were found. No relevant task content was left unreviewed; generic catalog rules for unrelated variants were not semantically audited because they cannot affect this variant. Submitted programs were not executed, and the network-backed visual judge was not run. The solver receives only the prompt and four source images, creates `output/final.psd` and `output/final.png` in Photoshop, and the protected evaluator checks artifact validity, matching renders, PSD topology, visible requirements, and reference-relative quality. License keys, accounts, tokens, and other credentials are not required from the contributor. Confidential, proprietary, or internal material may be evaluated as submitted evidence without requiring additional disclosure.\n\n**Special Screening:**\nNone\n\n**Recommended Changes:**\nThe submission already provides coherent instructions, authentic usable assets, protected references, editable-layer expectations, and a comprehensive evaluator. No changes are required.","reviewed_at":"2026-09-26T01:41:15.052147Z"},"claim":null}